Although Maguire has been lately lauded for his books
Wicked,and the December-released
Son of a Witch, I found my first experience with him truly disappointing. Maguire’s schtick is somewhat unique: he takes secondary characters in famous fables and tells their personal life stories, attempting to put a new spin on an old tale. The novels are targeted at adults, and since grown-up fairy tales are hard to come by these days, I was very much looking forward to reading his novels.
My friend, Bryce, purchased
Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West, and I purchased
Confessions of an Ugly Stepsister, that way we can swap books. When I began
Confessions… I had extremely high hopes, which, as most know, almost always leads to disappointment. However, I choose to believe that even if I had opened the covers not knowing a thing about it, I would have been let down.
The storyline itself – a third-person narrative about the “ugly” stepsister in Cinderella – could possibly work under different circumstances. It breaks the common mold, showing the pains and sufferings of Iris, the “ugly” stepsister, Ruth, the other stepsister, and Clara, the one we call Cinderella. The outline of the classic is there, but the fluff that Cinderella-lovers expect is not. The stepmother is indeed wicked, as the classic tells us, but the three sisters lack what it takes to make us care about their plots in life. Iris is the “fiery, spirited one”, I suppose to make up for her ugliness with personality. Unfortunately, Maguire fails to make us fall in love with anything about her, personality included. Ruth, the other stepsister, is mute and (what we assume to be) mentally challenged. She brings absolutely nothing to the length of the novel. Her character is meant to bring out Iris’ connection and compassion as a sister, but fails for the most part in that regard as well. Clara, our Cinderella counterpart, is nothing short of a selfish, whiny, spoiled brat. That portrayal would be fine if that is how she truly is, but somewhere in the middle of the book Maguire decides to try and make us like her, as though one morning he woke up and thought, “Eh, what the heck. Everyone can feel bad for her too.” Unfortunately, by the time he tries to pull that off, we are far too annoyed at her and disliking her to the point of no return. Moreover, our dislike of her is borderline apathetic.
That said, I will make very clear what I did not like: it bored me to death. The detail, the scenes, the character relationships, all of it: Boring. Many books get off to a very slow start, so I was hesitant to judge early, but then 150 pages crawled by almost painfully, and I realized that I was halfway through the novel and I was still waiting for it to start.
Perhaps Maguire was hoping for a less-glamorous portrayal of a classic story. If this was the case, he managed it, but missed the mark on every other account. Nearing the end of the book, I still did not feel close to any of the characters. Rather, I was just waiting for it to end, not really caring which way the plot went or who ended up where.
I still have yet to read
Wicked. I am going to put away my negative thoughts on Maguire’s style and begin
Wicked with a clean slate. Hopefully
Confessions… was the weakest example of his works.